Stretching when partner is overcalled

This question was asked to: Julian Pottage

Question

I have been asked to submit to you for your view on it: North opened 1H which was overcalled 2D by east. I (south) had: S: AK543 H:J95 D: J C: 9752 Is it always right to stretch? I didn’t think I could bid 3H as that would promise 4 card support (we dont play 5 card majors). Should I have bid 2Spades?

Julian Pottage's Answer

2S usually shows 10+ points. Having partial heart support and a shortage in the opposing suit is good, while a singleton jack could be useless. it is a close 3-way decision between 2H, double and 2S. As you say, playing 4-card majors, 3H is not an option. On balance I slightly favour doubling but neither 2S nor 2H are terrible bids.

What do you think? Click here for Julian Pottage's Answer

Questions are taken from the Bernard Magee Bridge forum which is available with BMB paid memberships.